|
Reviewed
by Elaine Chiew
I
had a good
chuckle when the main character, also named Nam, in Nam
Le’s first story in this debut Love
and Honor and Pity
and
Pride and Compassion and Sacrifice,
took note of the prevalence of
ethnic lit. "It’s hot," says a literary
agent. "I’m sick of ethnic lit. It’s full
of descriptions of exotic food," says one of his friends. "You can’t
tell if the language is spare because
the author intended it that way, or because he didn’t have
the vocab."
Nam Le then sets out in the next
six stories in this collection to
disprove the fact that he’s just another ethnic minority
writer. He’s not that guy, because he will write about
teenage contract killers from Colombia (Cartagena
)
or white middle-aged
painters disenfranchised from their daughters (
Meeting
Elise
).
He’s not afraid of far-off locales
– a fishing town
in provincial Australia (Halfhead
Bay
)
or Tehran (Tehran
Calling
)
or a
refugee boat adrift on the South China Seas (The
Boat).
He will delve
into historical imaginings and the voice of a little girl in Hiroshima
before the atomic bomb (Hiroshima).
This
ambitious, wide-ranging debut
is impressive not just because the writer is so young and fearless in
his imaginative explorations, it is also noteworthy for its prose
– at times, hard and spare and sad, with echoes of
Jhumpa
Lahiri
,
at other times, lyrical, replete with breathtaking
landscape
descriptions edged with a cold ethereal and poetic beauty. His facial
close-ups of the heartbreak and confusion and loneliness and hope of
his main characters feel like the unwavering and private aim of a movie
camera. It’s as if Nam Le is determinedly proving to us that
his vocab goes beyond that of an ethnic writer. Perhaps it’s
a function of having had a prestigious education at the Iowa
Writers’ Workshop that the scatter of words like "striate", "strafe",
"rime" and "rinse" appear in so
much literary academic fiction, nevertheless, Nam Le seems to find new
ways to manipulate a supple language to give us his "scree of
bodies" and "inlet of neck" in
The
Boat
,
a face "crimped in fear" and a truck ripping "skins of water off the
bitumen" in Halfhead
Bay.
Of
the seven stories in this collection, the ones that stand out the
most to me are
Love
and
Honor and
Pity
and Pride and Compassion and
Sacrifice,
Halfhead
Bay,
and
The
Boat.
Strangely, perhaps not
coincidentally, all three deal with the theme of parental love and
parent-child relationship. In
Love
and Honor,
Nam’s father
comes to visit him in Iowa and the story explores the burdens a son
confronts in a father’s war stories; in
Halfhead
Bay
,
James’ mother is dying of multiple sclerosis and the scenes
that involve James’ inarticulate and conflicted feelings
about his dying mother and his father’s expectations are some
of the most poignant and heartbreaking in the story; and in
The
Boat,
this grim, unrelenting story that documents a refugee boat’s
progress across the South China Seas, as the engines fail and the water
and food supplies dwindle, the heroine’s attempt to save a
small Vietnamese boy’s life is harrowing indeed.
In
each of these stories, Nam Le demonstrates considerable technical
skill – that of looking at the heart of a story from an angle
(and yet, never sacrificing story-depth or emotional involvement), and
in doing so, he lets the reader breathe. But in
The
Boat,
this
technique makes me want to stand up and applaud – ostensibly,
the story structures around a grim day-to-day account on the seas, and
any writer will attest, it is not easy to sustain emotion and suspense
with this kind of unrelenting, monotonous grimness (we’re
talking about bodily fluids and secretions and smells and illness and
the deaths of multiples among two hundred bodies packed into a boat
meant for fifteen). By doing so, Nam Le places this boy’s
illness within the perspective of two hundred other suffering bodies,
the story becomes swallowable, but the heartbreak is crushingly
magnified – their suffering seeps into your consciousness
with the kind of unforgettable anguish that keeps you from being able
to go to sleep.
I
found it curious that the main character,
James’ nemesis in
Halfhead
Bay
is rumored to have killed a
Chinese poacher, and some racist sentiments voiced by the nemesis and
his uncle towards ‘chinks’ make their way into the
story – the phenomenon of an ethnic writer looking at ethnic
slurs is inherently politically-fraught, and the effect is strangely
metaphoric, like placing two mirrors at 90-degree angles to each other,
so that they endlessly reflect. I held my breath, wondering if Nam Le
will inevitably reveal his leanings here, or stay fictionally neutral;
he does the latter but leaves you wondering if he’s merely
holding his tongue. For now.
The
remaining stories in this collection are more uneven in terms of
effect and voice, and the jury may well be out on whether this debut is
susceptible to the accusations of "armchair
traveller" writing. Is this question apropos, however?
Aren’t you by definition an "armchair
traveller" if you choose to write "what you
don’t know"?
The
question for literary excellence
at these top echelons is not whether the stories are authentic and
believable. It’s whether they can shed literary illumination
in the sense that no one else but this writer could have written them.
This second criteria is often the one that trips up writers writing far
beyond what they know; for example, I’ve no doubt that the
details and setting of
Cartagena
are exactingly researched and
presented, in
Tehran
Calling,
the setting is vividly described, and in
Hiroshima,
the use of Japanese anti-American war slogans is authentic
and true, and yet, in these stories, I want to say that Le
hasn’t yielded the essence of these characters to us.
Undoubtedly, the stories that ring most poignantly tend to be those
that don’t stray too far from home; yet, I will say,
The
Boat
- both the book and the namesake story - is an incredible feat of
imagination, emotional stamina and storytelling skills. This is a
talented writer eminently well-worth watching and he’s only
just begun.
Read an extract from one of
the stories in this collection on Random House.
| Elaine
Chiew
lives in London, England. Her work has most recently won
First Prize in the Bridport International Short Story Competition, and
also appeared in the following anthologies: See You Next Tuesday: The
Second Coming (Better Non Sequitur Media), Best of the Web 2008 (Dzanc
Books), Hobart (the Games Issue), Alimentum (Issue 6) and a number of
online publications such as Wigleaf, Night Train, Summerset Review,
Storyglossia, et. al. She blogs at http://www.elainepchiew.blogspot.com. |
|
Publisher: Canongate
Publication
Date:
2008
Paperback/Hardback? Hardback
First
collection?: Yes
Awards: 2008
Library Journal Best Books of the Year;
Short story from this collection, Cartagena,
won a Pushcart Prize
Book website: Nam Le Online
Author
bio: Nam
Le was born in Vietnam and raised in Australia. He has
received the Pushcart Prize, the Michener-Copernicus Society of America
Award, and fellowships from the Iowa Writers’ Workshop, the Fine Arts
Work Center in Provincetown, and Phillips Exeter Academy. His fiction
has appeared in venues including Best
New American Voices, Best Australian Stories, Best American Nonrequired
Reading, Zoetrope: All-Story, A Public Space and Harvard Review. He
divides his time between Australia and the United States.
Buy
this book (used or
new) from:
The
Publisher's Website: Random House
The
Author's
website
AbeBooks
Amazon

Book
Depository
Powell's
BetterWorldBooks.Com
And...don't
forget your local booksellers and independent book shops! Visit IndieBound.org to find an independent
bookstore near
you in the US
If
you liked this book you might also like....
Yiyun
Li "A Thousand
Years
of Good Prayers"
Jhumpa Lahiri "Unaccustomed
Earth"
and "Interpreter of
Maladies"
Junot Diaz "Drown"
Rattawut Laphcharoensap "Sightseeing"
Daniyal Mueenuddin "In Other Rooms. Other Wonders"
What
other reviewers thought:
New York
Times
FT.com
Guardian
Popmatters
International
Herald Tribune
San
Francisco Chronicle
Readings.com.au
BookFox
The
Age
Quarterly
Conversation
Matilda
Esquire
|